The Punchline
A Play in Ten
[The set should resemble a rooftop. When lights come up we see 1 setting up a camera on a tripod downstage center. He spends a moment or two fixing the angle of the shot, before stepping back and delivering his first monologue]
1: You’re dying. You’re dying right now. And you don’t care. You’re just going to sit there for the next ten minutes, and lose your life in me. I’m not that special. Anything I have to say you can figure out for yourself, if you just cared. No one cares, though. But you’re going to sit there and pretend like you do. Who are you trying to impress? Or are you just being lazy. [Beat] But we’re here aren’t we. Might as well go through with it. My name…it doesn’t really matter what you call me. It’s not important. It’s not like you’ll be able to call me by it. I can tell you its Latin for happiness, though. I think it suits me. People tell me it suits me. I wish my name was something normal though. I wish it was Lee. I’ve always liked the name Lee. But I’m here. And I’m not Lee. I’m just…I’m me. And I only have one thing to tell you. Or ask. I think I should ask you. Why…Why do we laugh?
2: [Entering from unseen from the Right] We find something funny.
3: [Entering from unseen from the Left] You find this funny?
2: I’m sorry.
3: Do you. Find this. Funny.
2: [Beat] Define funny.
3: That’s what he’s asking isn’t he?
2: Maybe. But what is he asking? What are you asking?
1: I just…I don’t know. I don’t like the question very much. Could you answer the question?
2: Fine, fine. What were you asking?
3: This situation. Does it bring a chirp of happiness to your brain, a flutter to your heart, spasms to your diaphragm, or incomprehensible gibbering to your lips?
2: Funny. [Beat] Are you asking if this situation is humorous? Does it make me giggle? Would I laugh at it? No. Is it unfamiliar? Do I find the lack of congruity between expectation and reality disturbing? Maybe. Maybe this unsettles me, but maybe that can be funny too.
1: No, wait, that’s not what I meant to ask. Let me think of another way to ask what I mean.
3: This?
2: What.
3: I’m just wondering. You said this unsettles you. This what? This question? This place? The fact that you can’t seem to make a decision even when it’s staring you in the face?
2: Maybe.
3: Maybe fucking what?
2:Maybe this place unsettles me. Maybe your question does. Or maybe it’s just you.
3: [Innocently] I unsettle you.
1: [Suddenly] What’s the difference? Between what’s funny and…
2: What we laugh at?
1: —and what we laugh at. Yes. What’s the difference?
2: You mean why do we chuckle at one, yet fidget, squirm, and otherwise avert ourselves from the other? Personal taste, maybe.
3: Maybe. Maybe, maybe, maybe. You are so damn vague it’s unsettling. What the hell is with these questions anyways? In a few minutes none of it is going to matter.
1: It’s just…something happened today and…
3: [Mocking] And?
1: …I don’t know.
3: Shocking.
2: [Ignoring 3] What happened?
3: He doesn’t know.
1: I know. I just don’t know where to start from. It’s a funny story. But not the kind you laugh at. Except you’re going to. I know it.
3: Don’t go making promises you can’t keep.
2: Could you grow even the tiniest amount of empathy, or compassion? Not even that. Interest. Could you develop genuine interest in someone other than yourself? For five minutes, even?
3: Why not? None of this matters.
2: It does to me. It could to you. [To 2] Go ahead.
1: It’s not all that interesting, and really I just…I… [2 reassures 1 with a soft look]…My day started alright. I mean, it started like it always does, which is alright, but I was wishing something different would happen. Just…something extraordinary. Not like over the top extraordinary. Just, something not normal. Anything to break the mediocrity. Maybe a girl could smile at me, or maybe I could find twenty bucks on the ground. Or maybe a car could come around the corner and hit me. Just something. So I wandered out to downtown, so that if something was looking to happen to me, I’d be easier to find. I wandered through a few shops, but ended up sitting at a bench by one of the street corners. And I waited there. [Beat] But nothing happened. Nothing at all, and I waited all morning.
3: [Unable to control his mirth] Fucking hell.
2: Seriously? Seriously.
3: What? Come on, I’ve seen vegetables with more dignity.
1: You’re laughing. I knew you’d laugh. I shouldn’t have brought anything up, I just knew it.
2: No, no. Listen, don’t worry about the asshole. He’d find a way to get a kick out of the holocaust if he was bored enough. [To 1] Go ahead.
1: I don’t remember where I was going with this.
2: [Gently] Could you try to? I’d like to know how it ends.
3: I could tell you that.
2: It’s not time for that yet. Why don’t you listen? You never bother to listen.
3: He’s made up his mind. What is my listening going to do to change anything?
1: It could be different. [2 & 3 both turn to the forgotten 1] It could. What if I stopped. I could stop right now, I could…I could…
2: [Genuine] We’ve tried that. We have. Trying, it brought us here.
3: Just finish your fucking story and let’s get this over with.
[2 gives 3 a look of concern, before giving 1 a nod of approval]
1: I got hungry, and bored, while I was waiting. Really bored. So I got lunch from one of those taco stands. It wasn’t very good, it was just the first place I stopped at. But it was something to do while I waited. After a while, another hour, I decided to head home. So I took the subway, or I was going to anyways when something happened. When it found me. The thing I had been waiting for all day, maybe my entire life.
3: Something. It. The thing. He’s worse than you.
[2 is focused on the story]
1: This man, looked like a banker or maybe an accountant. He had this blazer with the patches on the elbows and a button up shirt underneath. Some pants that matched the blazer and this…stripey tie. Afterwards, I thought that maybe they were the nicest clothes he owned. Or maybe just the ones he felt comfortable in. He looked like he worked in an office, he wasn’t old. He wasn’t young either though. He could have been anybody. He could have just gotten back from Iraq or maybe he was a CEO. He could have been the manager at a Wendy’s…I don’t know. I just remember seeing him as I passed through the turnstile. He kept staring up at the clock, didn’t take his eyes off of it for a second. I could see the strain in his neck.
3: Who cares, get to the good part.
2: Would you—
1: I’m boring you though. It doesn’t matter about the details. I understand. The point is that after a few minutes, he moved onto the platform and then…well, he kind of hopped down onto the tracks and laid down. At first I didn’t know what to make of it.
2: He was trying to kill himself.
1: Well, the train wasn’t there yet, but…yeah, he was trying to kill himself.
3: And?
2: And?
3: People throw themselves in front of trains all the time. It happens every day.
1: See, the thing is though, his wife showed up.
3: Finally something interesting. [2 gives 3 a reproachful look] What? No one gives a shit about the everyday.
1: I think it was his wife. She was crying hysterically, pushing her way through the stiles and shoving through the crowd. She was waving something through the air, this piece of paper. I couldn’t see what was written on it, but she wielded it like a badge. Maybe she hoped the crowd would open up for her, or understand, or care.
3: [To 2] Imagine that, people caring.
1: But they were focused on the husband, most of the people didn’t even notice the woman until she was out on the platform, reaching out with the paper like it was one of those life ring things.
2: Preservers.
1: Preservers, yeah. Life preserver. That’s what she was trying to do anyways, she was trying to save him, to get him off the tracks. Waving that paper and blubbering and yelling and crying and just making this constant stream of high-pitched noise. Everyone else just…they just kind of watched. Like they had just paid 5 bucks to see a matinee. I’m sure some of them were scared that the train might come, and they didn’t want to be down there with him when it did. But a part of it…they just watched. Like it was TV.
2: Bastards.
3: Humans.
1: And then we heard it, all of us. We heard the train and saw the light coming around the corner. And this husband looks up for the first time and sees it. He sees what he’s doing, and then looks up and notices his wife there, and something snapped inside of him. He started scrambling up the platform and his wife was pulling him up and the train was getting louder and the light was growing across the walls and people were pressing closer to get a better view [Beat] and then it was over. The husband was back on the platform, his wife sobbing all over him, and people were applauding and clapping each other on the back as if they had done something to help. [Beat] And then the paper slipped out of the woman’s hands, and I could see it hit the ground.
2: What was on it?
1: I couldn’t see all of it. The only words I had time to read were at the bottom. “I’m sorry” That’s all I could see on it.
3: Suicide note.
1: The thing is the wife kind of looked down at it, and so did the husband and they had this moment…the husband was…
2: Regretful, maybe?
3: Embarrassed more like it.
2: Saved by Love?
3: Saved by Fear.
2: Rationality.
3: Stupidity.
1: It was like an emotional montage playing across his face. And he reached down for the note. I don’t know why, I mean if it was a suicide note—I think it was anyways—then why would you want to pick it up. Who cares? Right? And the wife went to grab it too, so they’re both reaching for this scrap of paper and they kind of bump heads. It was kind of funny. I laughed. I did. I laughed at the two of them. I kept laughing as the husband fell backwards onto the tracks and the train finally came in. I laughed the whole time. Why…Why the fuck did I laugh?
[Silence from 2]
3: It was funny. Wasn’t it? Isn’t that whole situation kind of hilarious in a fucked up way?
1: Someone died right in front of me and I just…like an idiot. Like an asshole.
2: You were safe.
3: What?
2: He was, wasn’t he? Weren’t you.
3: He laughed, because he was safe?
2: It wasn’t him on the tracks. Maybe you thought it could never be you down there on the tracks. Why would it? Human beings laugh as a sign of safety. It’s just a biological fact.
1: It was inhuman. I was inhuman.
3: Don’t go giving the species too noble of a name.
2: Anyone could have been there, seen that, and laughed. That’s humanity. Sometimes we weep, sometimes we laugh, it’s all context and taste.
1: No, it’s more basic than that. If we laugh to show our safety, to reassure ourselves. I laughed…I laughed because it could have been me on the tracks. And it wasn’t.I laughed because it’s a joke. All of it. Life. We live for a few decades and for what? What’s all this pain, all this love, all this business, all of these accomplishments worth? What are we worth? We die. We leave it all behind. Friends, family, lovers. What’s it all worth?
2: We make a better world for those we leave behind.
3: Or a worse one. Hey, it’s an impact, alright?
1: But what’s the point. In a few decades after us things can revert, things can get worse or better without us. Humanity doesn’tjust build on itself, humanity is an ocean. Rising and falling, each crest bigger than the next, each valley lower than the one before. Eventually we’ll wipe ourselves off the earth and then, in a few million years everything will reset and repeat. What’s the goddamn point?
3: There isn’t one. There’s just life. There’s you, here and now, and…that’s it. We have no true effect on the world.
2: That’s bullshit.
3: Even if it is, what does it matter? He’s right. We’re a blue speck in an ocean of black. What do we matter? To whom do we matter?
2: God. Our friends. Our families.
3: A figment without a breath of life and a few corpses decaying to slow to realize it themselves.
1: [Through out this speech 1 takes closer and closer steps to the edge of the roof] It doesn’t matter…except…it’s kind of funny. The whole condition. Life is a big joke and death…death is the punchline. That’s why I laughed, because this man, this human being found the end of his joke on the tracks in front of me. I laughed because I understood what others are too afraid to…because they don’t want to admit the truth. So I only have one thing to tell you. Or ask. I should ask it. I’d like to ask you. To laugh. [1 steps off the roof]
[Lights fade and the camera is left as the only source of illumination on the stage. And then, it turns off]


2
